Jump to content
Product Design Forums

Treasurebox
admin

The Winner Is Streamliner

Vote for your favorite entry  

30 members have voted

  1. 1. Who has the best entry?

    • [url=http://www.productdesignforums.com/topic/12840-azuro1125s-submission/]azuro1125[/url]
      1
    • [url=http://www.productdesignforums.com/topic/12914-shower/]streamliner[/url]
      12
    • [url=http://www.productdesignforums.com/topic/12955-capacitive-touch-switch-for-the-disabled/]gigawat007[/url]
      2
    • [url=http://www.productdesignforums.com/topic/12892-my-entry/]Gerivta[/url]
      3
    • [url=http://www.productdesignforums.com/topic/12907-meeteat/]JONGHDESIGN[/url]
      11
    • [url=http://www.productdesignforums.com/topic/12938-danhibberts-entry-design-for-the-disadvantaged/]DanHibbert[/url]
      0
    • [url=http://www.productdesignforums.com/topic/12945-smart-plant-pro/]SamBan[/url]
      1


Recommended Posts

Thank you for participating this 6th Design Challenge. Also thanks to everyone for giving feedback to the participants.

We hope you have enjoyed this Design Challenge!

 

You can now start voting for your favorite entry until 11th of June. All entries that have shown development and a design are included in the poll. Entries that only show research work are not included. Click on the member name so see his/her entry.

Entries with 5 or more progress images in their thread might receive a bonus vote. The way we do this will be in the end of the voting. If we have a tie, this might sway the score one way or another.

 

The winner will be announced on the 12th of June.

 

Feel free to post your comments in this thread, for instance why you voted on a particular entry.

 

PS: Do not try to abuse the poll with creating fake accounts to vote.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Azuro1125: Neat idea... but the solution had a few issues. Can't be molded (severe undercuts), and you can't put your feet under the desk (ignoring human factors. Most people put their feet under the desk quite far. Does not look stackable, so shipping would be expensive.

 

Streamliner: Solid entry. Only change I'd make is that the 3d renderings do NOT have perspective turned on. Come on man, perspective is what separates us from them (engineers)! :)

 

Gigawatt: Not design. At all. And it's on the market already, apparently? Just... no.

 

Gerivta: Spell check. Grammar. Needs more development in general in terms of human factors, production, shipping, and mechanical systems.

 

JONGHDESIGN: Nice work, solid sketching/modeling skills, but the concept needs more development. Right away, collected rainwater is not sanitary; go look inside a rain barrel and all the nasty bacteria that grows in it. Hence why it's only used for watering plants. Again, fantastic sketches/modeling/rendering, but the idea needed a bit more revisions.

 

DanHibbert: What?

 

SamBan: For every problem there is an overly complicated solution. This is a perfect example. The world doesn't need microchips and electronics in everything; I've seen small clay worms that cost less than $3 that accomplish the exact same thing. You water the plants, the worms turn dark red. When the soil is dry, the clay dries to a chalky white.

 

SO:

 

I give my vote to Streamliner. Great sketches, great development, I can see the way you tackled different problems, just totally rock solid all around! JUST REMEMBER TO TURN ON PERSPECTIVE! :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

My favourite entries have to be streamliners shower concept and JONGHDESIGN's Meet & Greet. I loved the simplicity of the shower concept idea and the hands on modelling and development work which the other entries generally lacked.

 

The Meet & Greet is a fantastic concept and has been well presented with sketches and renderings. There is so much scope for further concept development.

 

Some of you may have noticed that my entry has been listed despite not being completed, please vote for one of the other participants who have put together a complete entry.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You caught me on the draft angle. I noticed it when I did my final render. That was supposed to extend all the way around the skirt of the desk. The undercuts themselves should not have been too big of a problem with roto molding, as long as the parting line ran on the center of the desk. I was planning on creating a place in the footrest portion to be punched out after delivery, I dont know why I didn't. Thanks for the honest critiques.

 

Joe.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@Cash68 Thanks for your comment. The concept still has a lot of details to be engineered and exploited. Will do soon!

@Danhibbert Thanks for your comment!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was very impressed with Streamliners design for the shower and think it answered the brief brilliantly. Streamliner hasn't only thought about the design, but has thought about the materials and the process needed to make the product. It's a real solution to a real problem.

 

I know it's been designed for third world countries but I think it would be great if it could be folded away and easily transportable for festival goers and campers alike. Possible place in the market for this product(?) great job!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Congratulations to Streamliner with his affordable shower design for the third world!

 

The solidThinking 8.5 Inspired commercial license will ship to Streamliner very soon.

 

Unfortunately the prize for the member with the most reputation points is not going anywhere, as there is no specific member who does have the most points. I will reserve this prize for the next challenge, and then I hope that member will be more encouraged to offer feedback and give reputation points to the ones who offered valuable feedback.

 

Anyways, thanks to all the members who have voted.

We hope to see you in a next design challenge.

 

Cheers!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

×

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.